Monday, January 12, 2015

The Subtle Truth


The evident psychological repercussion that O’Brien reveals by contradiction and repetition is confusion.  O’Brien explains that what goes on in war stories is not easily explainable.   He starts his story off by telling his account of Curt Lemon’s death.  What’s interesting is O’Brien tells this account differently through the eyes of a couple soldiers.  In each account, the way and place in which Lemon died was unalike.  I believe O’Brien did this to point out that the actual story wasn’t important.  This is because as time goes by, it’s hard to recollect the details that occurred in each event. However what’s important and easy to remember was the message behind the story.  Love, Sorrow and fear were significant ideas featured in each narrative.  When those ideas are combined, it’s easy to see how PTSD can trigger major anxiety from war.  The other unconventional technique used in “How to Tell a War Story” is contradiction.  This technique was seen in O’Brien’s account of Rat’s encounter with the water buffalo.  Rat befriends the animal by stroking its nose. Then suddenly Rat brutally tortures the animal. This event happens days after Lemon dies. It is as if the repercussion of Lemon’s death is Rat’s sorrowful, confused state of mind.  Lemon’s death had a domino effect.  The way Rat tortured the buffalo left his peers in disarray.  War Stories are not about details, but rather the perceived truth that is subtle, and hard to find.

2 comments:

  1. I found your take on the story interesting. Specifically, your last sentence of a war story is not about the details but the truth that is hard to find. I agree with your point about this. Because war is often a hard event to go back to, especially for a soldier who was directly affected by a war, it is often hard to write about what truly happened. It is definitely a possibility of that being apart of PTSD - to falsify or fabricate some parts of what actually happened and create this other reality so the author can escape from what actually happened. It's definitely something to think about!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like how you saw this story. It opened up my eyes to a different perspective on that chapter of the book. It is hard to find the truth in these stories and I like how you dug deeper to see the real feelings and true meaning of why these soldiers acted the way they did.

    ReplyDelete