It is not an incredible stretch to presume that the events
which the story of Sand Queen details are ones which would quickly be dubbed
falsehoods if not for the fact that much of the plot was initially derived from
the experiences of real women living and working in the warzones of Iraq. The
attitudes which the character of Kate, an American soldier, is forced to
contend with by her male peers truly beggar belief – everything from the
nicknames given to her (“Tits,” “Pinkass,” and “party girl,” among others) to
an attempted sexual assault by her superior reads more as a warning to women
against joining the military than an extrapolation of real-life experiences
described in interviews by actual female soldiers.
However, this is where we see the
true power of Helen Benedict’s novel come into play: through exposing a series
of harsh realities real women who are represented by Kate and Naema must
undergo in a war-torn land, she informs her readers that nothing in this world
is simply black and white. Many of the patriotic American “heroes” are lascivious
and treat Kate in a truly vile manner, something which suggests that while a
man may live and die for this country, this does not necessarily make him a
good (or even pleasant) person. This challenges image of a just, upright
soldier many readers likely have ingrained into them in an American context,
and the divide in attitude between people like Jimmy and people like Mack
towards their female co-worker calls to attention the fact that sexual harassment
is no more acceptable in a war setting than an office one.
Very Interesting Analysis! Perhaps it is an American custom to be brainwashed into thinking all soldiers overseas are doing the best of deeds, however it is very easy for the male soldier to resort to these sexist tendencies as you explained. I like how you explained not everything is black and white which is important in order for the reader to not be so naïve when it comes to understanding the true realities of war through a novel. I also feel Iraqi as well as Muslim women are constantly being seen as oppressed which is more of stereotype meanwhile the American soldier attitude towards women can be seen as worse and even more oppressive.
ReplyDelete